Quotation Pernkopf-Konhäusner, Katharina, Brandl, Julia. 2011. Variations in evaluative repertoires: Comparing employee perspectives on training and development in Germany and Russia. Personnel Review 40 (5): 589-606.




Purpose - While it is acknowledged that societal context matters for employee expectations on training and development, the complexity of this relationship is still little explored. This paper aims to study which higher-order principles employees of a German and Russian company use to justify their views on beneficial training and development in order to identify how evaluative repertoires differ between the two settings. Design/methodology/approach - Building on interviews conducted in two professional services firms in Germany and Russia, the paper identifies patterns in the repertoire that employees use for evaluating training and development activities at each research site. Findings - The findings reveal that employees working for the German company predominantly use the industrial principle for justifying their views on training and development. In contrast, employees in the Russian company apply market, industrial and domestic principles with a tendency for long-term employees more often to justify their views using the market principle. Research limitations/implications - The case comparison points to variations in the evaluative repertoire that the paper explains with the societal context of Germany and Russia. By examining evaluative repertoires, companies learn what employees expect from training and development. Originality/value - Applying convention theory, the paper introduces a promising, but so far neglected approach for linking employee expectations with societal context and for comparing boundaries between people across different settings.


Press 'enter' for creating the tag

Publication's profile

Status of publication Published
Affiliation WU
Type of publication Journal article
Journal Personnel Review
Citation Index SSCI
Language English
Title Variations in evaluative repertoires: Comparing employee perspectives on training and development in Germany and Russia
Volume 40
Number 5
Year 2011
Page from 589
Page to 606
URL http://dx.doi.org/10.1108/00483481111154450


Pernkopf, Katharina (Former researcher)
Brandl, Julia (Former researcher)
Interdisciplinary Institute for Management and Organizational Behavior IN (Details)
Google Scholar: Search