Quotation Yolles, Maurice, Fink, Gerhard. 2009. Migrating personality theories Part 2: towards a theory of the balanced personality? Kybernetes 38 (9): 1461-1490.




Purpose of this paper:Some personality schemas are seen to compete with others, but are they really complimentary? Two trait approaches, MBTI and Mindscape theory, which are normally considered to be competitive, shall be migrated into a more complex modeling space using Knowledge Cybernetics, when they are shown to have a complimentary potential. Design/methodology/approach: The paper uses the meta-framework of Knowledge Cybernetics part of the relevantial universe identified by Maruyama, to migrate different theoretical approaches and relate them. A consequence is the possible development of a more sophisticated trait theory that is capable of providing more complex information about personality. Findings: The findings indicate that current type theories are not necessarily stand-alone, but may be seen as complementary within a broader conceptual framework. Research limitations/implications (if applicable): This paper is limited to the investigation of MBTI. However, it offers a generic approach that can be applied to other solitary theories like MBTI. Practical implications: The paper leads to the possibility of improved explanatory power for a type theory than is currently possible. What is original / value of paper? Very little comparative work has been done relating representations of MBTI and Mindscape theory. This also appears to be the first serious extensive direct comparison between any form of MBTI and Mindscapes has appeared. Knowledge Cybernetics uses Habermas three world theory and shows that it is possible to consider MBTI and Mindscape theory as conceptually distinct and complementary, and together contributing to a new way of exploring the field of personality theory.


Press 'enter' for creating the tag

Publication's profile

Status of publication Published
Affiliation WU
Type of publication Journal article
Journal Kybernetes
Citation Index SCI
Language English
Title Migrating personality theories Part 2: towards a theory of the balanced personality?
Volume 38
Number 9
Year 2009
Page from 1461
Page to 1490
Reviewed? Y
URL http://www.emeraldinsight.com/0368-492X.htm


Fink, Gerhard (Former researcher)
Yolles, Maurice (Liverpool John Moores University, United Kingdom)
Institute for International Business (Zapkau) (Details)
Research Institute for European Affairs FI (Details)
Research areas (Ă–STAT Classification 'Statistik Austria')
5324 Organizational research (Details)
5513 Behavioural psychology (Details)
Google Scholar: Search